In early April 2025, the US enacted sweeping new import tariffs, marking one of the decade’s most significant trade policy shifts. For retailers and e-commerce companies, this tariff shock represents an immediate jump in the cost of goods sold and a complex new variable in supply chains.
Immediate Cost Pressures and Margin Squeeze
The most immediate impact of the tariffs is a surge in input costs for retailers. A Yale analysis estimates that overall clothing prices will rise about 17% in the US due to the 2025 tariffs, far outpacing other categories. Such increases squeeze retailers’ gross margins since many apparel and consumer goods sellers operate on low single-digit margins to begin with. Analysts have warned that major US chains will likely see a substantial hit to their profit margins because of these import duties.
Retailers are responding by considering price hikes and cost savings. In fact, multiple companies moved quickly to announce price increases on products to offset tariffs. Chinese fast-fashion e-commerce giants Shein and Temu said they would raise US prices starting April 25. Even premium US retailers like Williams-Sonoma and RH indicated they expect to implement upward price adjustments. These moves signal that retailers feel they have little choice but to pass on a portion of the higher costs to consumers despite the risk to sales volumes.
Meanwhile, retailers are aggressively looking for internal offsets, such as tightening expense management and inventory control, to protect their bottom lines. “We’ll be focused on keeping prices as low as we can and managing our inventory and expenses well,” Walmart CEO Doug McMillon told investors, emphasizing that the company will leverage its scale to absorb shocks where possible. Such strategies imply near-term margin compression as retailers juggle absorbing costs versus raising prices. Many companies will likely accept lower margins in the short run to maintain market share and customer loyalty.
Market Reaction and Stock Performance
In the days after the April 2 announcement, retail and e-commerce stocks sold off sharply. Many retail-focused names underperformed the broader market in April. For example, by the close of April 2, Walmart’s stock had initially slipped nearly 9% from its pre-announcement level, and Target saw an even deeper plunge, down over 30% YTD by late April. Analysts and investors grew concerned that earnings would suffer in upcoming quarters, particularly for retailers unable to quickly mitigate the tariffs.
However, volatility has been extreme, and some relief rallies followed policy adjustments. When President Trump announced a partial 90-day tariff pause on April 9, the market surged in relief. The S&P 500 jumped 7%, and the tech-heavy Nasdaq leaped over 9% that day. Retail stocks rebounded as well, as Walmart’s shares recouped their losses and jumped to about 9.6% higher by the close of April 9, after the company reaffirmed its annual forecasts and the tariff pause eased worst-case fears. Walmart’s decision to maintain its full-year sales and income outlook and pledge to keep prices low was taken as a positive sign that the largest retailer will likely weather the storm.
Supply Chain Strains and Strategic Shifts
The tariffs are forcing retailers and e-commerce companies to rethink their supply chains. In the short term, many importers rushed to get shipments in ahead of tariff implementation to blunt the impact. Logistics providers reported early spikes in air freight demand. However, in the long term, if tariffs persist, sourcing strategies will inevitably shift. Retailers are looking to diversify away from China and shift orders to countries with relatively lower tariff rates. Some large retailers will likely turn increasingly to near-shoring or on-shoring production where feasible.
Retailers are also investing in technology and efficiency to adapt. As supply chain costs rise, merchants are looking to supply chain management to find savings. Automation in warehouses and logistics can help offset higher import fees by squeezing out other operational costs. In the long run, the retailers should build agility into their supply chains through multi-country sourcing, renegotiating with suppliers to share tariff costs, or even redesigning products to use more US-made components.
Consumer Behavior and Pricing Strategies
American consumers ultimately will feel the effects of these tariffs. Early signs indicate a mixed response. In some categories, consumers have rushed to buy big-ticket items before prices rise further. For instance, there are upticks in car purchases and appliance sales in anticipation of tariff-driven price hikes. At the same time, overall consumer spending is showing signs of slowing as households reckon with higher costs and uncertainty.
Notably, consumers will change what they buy and how they buy. With new tariffs in place, domestically produced goods and alternative brands will likely gain appeal. E-commerce trends suggest some shoppers are turning to the secondary market and refurbished goods to avoid tariff-inflated prices. Retailers are crafting their pricing strategies carefully in this environment. Many have held off on immediate across-the-board price hikes, instead selectively raising prices on the most affected categories while keeping everyday staples competitively priced.
About SG Analytics
SG Analytics (SGA) is a global leader in data-driven research and analytics, empowering Fortune 500 clients across BFSI, Technology, Media & Entertainment, and Healthcare. A trusted partner for lower middle market investment banks and private equity firms, SGA provides offshore analysts with seamless deal life cycle support. Our integrated back-office research ecosystem, including database access, design support, domain experts, and tech-enabled automation, helps clients win more mandates and execute deals with precision.
Founded in 2007, SGA is a Great Place to Work® certified firm with 1,600+ employees across the U.S., the UK, Switzerland, Poland, and India. Recognized by Gartner, Everest Group, and ISG and featured in the Deloitte Technology Fast 50 India 2023 and Financial Times APAC 2024 High Growth Companies, we continue to set industry benchmarks in data excellence.
